Back row (L–R): Michael Kostroff as Professor Plum, John Treacy Egan as Colonel Mustard, and Alex Mandell as Mr. Green; front row (L–R): Sarah Hollis as Miss Scarlet, Donna English as Mrs. White, and Kathy Fitzgerald as Mrs. Peacock. Courtesy of Paper Mill Playhouse; photo by Evan Zimmerman/MurphyMade

Left (top to bottom): Sarah Hollis as Miss Scarlet, John Treacy Egan as Colonel Mustard, Kathy Fitzgerald as Mrs. Peacock, Donna English as Mrs. White, Isabelle McCalla as Yvette, Michael Kostroff as Professor Plum, Alex Mandell as Mr. Green; right: Mark Price as Wadsworth. Courtesy of Paper Mill Playhouse; photo by Evan Zimmerman/MurphyMade

Left to right: Sarah Hollis as Miss Scarlet, Alex Mandell as Mr. Green, Kathy Fitzgerald as Mrs. Peacock, Donna English as Mrs. White, Michael Kostroff as Professor Plum, and John Treacy Egan as Colonel Mustard. Courtesy of Paper Mill Playhouse; photo by Evan Zimmerman/MurphyMade