VENUE
Garden Theater
1187 North High Street Columbus, OH 43201
Description
Our most requested show of the season! Welcome to Joe’s Diner, where the pies are sweet, but the drama is even sweeter. Meet Jenna, a waitress with a knack for baking and a talent for getting herself into sticky situations. Stuck in a loveless marriage, she’s dreaming of a way out. Jenna’s life takes a turn when she unexpectedly finds herself with a bun in the oven. Suddenly, a baking contest and a new doctor in town offer a slice of hope.
With songs by Sara Bareilles like “Opening Up,” where the diner crew kicks off the day with a bang, and “She Used to Be Mine,” Jenna’s heart-wrenching anthem of self-discovery, you’ll be whisked away on a rollercoaster of emotions. And let’s not forget “Bad Idea,” the steamy duet with the new doctor in town that will have you questioning your own life choices.
The cast of quirky characters, including her sassy best friends and a boss who’s crustier than a day-old pie will serve up a delicious mix of humor, heart, and a dash of snark. Get ready for a musical that’s as satisfying as a perfectly baked pie – and just as messy!
Rated PG-13
Other Ways to Purchase Tickets
Call the CAPA Ticket Center at 614-469-0939.
Visit the CAPA Ticket Center at the Ohio Theatre (39 E. State Street).
June 2026
Sunday, June 07 | 7:00pm
BUY TICKETSWednesday, June 10 | 7:30pm
BUY TICKETSFriday, June 12 | 7:30pm
BUY TICKETSSaturday, June 13 | 2:00pm
ASL Interpretation and Audio Descriptions available at this showing.
BUY TICKETSSaturday, June 13 | 7:30pm
BUY TICKETSSaturday, June 13 | 7:30pm
BUY TICKETSSaturday, June 13 | 8:00pm
BUY TICKETSSaturday, June 13 | 8:00pm
BUY TICKETSSunday, June 14 | 1:00pm
BUY TICKETSSunday, June 14 | 2:00pm
BUY TICKETSSunday, June 14 | 6:30pm
BUY TICKETSWednesday, June 17 | 7:00pm
BUY TICKETSThursday, June 18 | 7:30pm
BUY TICKETSSaturday, June 20 | 1:00pm
BUY TICKETSSaturday, June 20 | 4:00pm
BUY TICKETSSaturday, June 20 | 7:00pm
BUY TICKETSSaturday, June 20 | 7:30pm
BUY TICKETSSaturday, June 20 | 8:00pm
BUY TICKETSSunday, June 21 | 2:00pm
BUY TICKETSThursday, June 25 | 7:30pm
BUY TICKETSFriday, June 26 | 7:30pm
BUY TICKETSSaturday, June 27 | 10:00am
BUY TICKETSSaturday, June 27 | 7:30pm
BUY TICKETSSaturday, June 27 | 8:00pm
BUY TICKETSSunday, June 28 | 2:00pm
BUY TICKETSAugust 2026
Friday, July 31 | 8:00pm
BUY TICKETSJuly 2026
Wednesday, July 01 | 7:30pm
BUY TICKETSThursday, July 02 | 7:30pm
BUY TICKETSFriday, July 03 | 8:00pm
BUY TICKETSSaturday, July 04 | 11:00am
BUY TICKETSWednesday, July 08 | 7:30pm
BUY TICKETSSaturday, July 11 | 4:00pm
BUY TICKETSSaturday, July 11 | 7:30pm
BUY TICKETSSaturday, July 11 | 8:00pm
BUY TICKETSSaturday, July 11 | 8:00pm
BUY TICKETSSunday, July 12 | 2:00pm
BUY TICKETSThursday, July 16 | 7:00pm
BUY TICKETSThursday, July 16 | 7:30pm
Audio Description is available at this showing.
BUY TICKETSSaturday, July 18 | 7:30pm
BUY TICKETSSaturday, July 18 | 8:00pm
BUY TICKETSSaturday, July 18 | 8:00pm
BUY TICKETSSunday, July 19 | 2:00pm
BUY TICKETSWednesday, July 22 | 7:30pm
BUY TICKETSFriday, July 24 | 7:30pm
BUY TICKETSSaturday, July 25 | 3:30pm
BUY TICKETSSaturday, July 25 | 4:00pm
BUY TICKETSSaturday, July 25 | 7:30pm
BUY TICKETSSaturday, July 25 | 8:00pm
BUY TICKETSSunday, July 26 | 2:00pm
BUY TICKETSMonday, July 27 | 3:30pm
BUY TICKETSTuesday, July 28 | 5:30pm
BUY TICKETSWednesday, July 29 | 7:30pm
BUY TICKETSThursday, July 30 | 7:30pm
BUY TICKETSFriday, July 31 | 7:00pm
BUY TICKETSFriday, July 31 | 7:30pm
BUY TICKETSFriday, July 31 | 8:00pm
BUY TICKETSFriday, July 31 | 10:00pm
BUY TICKETSSaturday, August 01 | 8:00pm
BUY TICKETS
Audio Description
Saturday, July 26 | 2:00 p.m.
ASL Interpretation
Sunday, July 27 | 2:00 p.m.
Presented By:
About Short North Stage
Short North Stage is a professional, regional theater dedicated to showcasing bold, inspiring, and entertaining performances. The intimate theater seats 275 audience members and takes place at the historic Garden Theater located in the dynamic Short North Arts District. Featuring talent from across the country and locally, our seasons are packed with performances that will captivate and inspire.